TUBULAR VS OPEN RED DOT: WHICH ONE IS BETTER FOR YOUR TACTICAL NEEDS?

Tubular vs Open Red Dot: Which One Is Better for Your Tactical Needs?

Tubular vs Open Red Dot: Which One Is Better for Your Tactical Needs?

Blog Article

In the field of tactical shooting, the red dot sight is highly favored equipment. Among them, tubular and open red dot sights each have their own characteristics. It is crucial to choose the type that suits one's own tactical needs.

 

Tubular red dot sight: A choice of protection and durability


 

Structure and Principle

The tubular red dot sight adopts a closed design with a cylindrical shell. Its working principle is that the reticle pattern is projected onto the specially coated lens through the LED light, forming a luminous point floating in the field of view for the shooter to aim at. The closed casing can effectively protect the internal optical components and electronic assemblies.

Advantage

  1. Outstanding protective performance: This closed structure makes it more durable and can withstand harsh conditions. In harsh environments such as sandstorms and heavy rain, it can prevent sand, rain and other substances from entering the interior, protect internal components from debris and weather conditions, and ensure stable operation in complex environments. For example, in desert operations or hunting activities in harsh weather conditions in the wild, the tubular red dot sight can continuously provide reliable aiming functions.

  2. High stability: Due to the relatively closed and compact internal structure, when affected by external force impact or recoil force of the firearm, the internal components are less likely to shift, which can better maintain the zero position and ensure the stability of shooting accuracy. This feature is particularly important for tactical scenarios that require frequent shooting.


Limitations

  1. The field of view is relatively narrow: Compared with the open red dot sight, the cylindrical shell of the tube type will limit the field of view to a certain extent. It may be slightly inferior in scenarios where a quick observation of the surrounding environment and the capture of multiple targets are required.

  2. The weight may be relatively large: To ensure protective performance, its casing is usually quite sturdy, resulting in an overall weight that may be slightly heavier than that of an open red dot sight. For some tactical operations with high requirements for equipment lightweighting, this may impose a certain burden.


 

Open red dot sight: Advantages in field of vision and speed


 

Structure and Principle

The open red dot sight uses an open window for aiming instead of a closed tube. It also uses LED lights to project the reticle pattern, but the open design makes its optical structure different in the presentation of the field of view.

Advantage

  • Wide field of vision: The open window design offers a broader field of vision, allowing shooters to more easily observe the surrounding environment of the target and quickly capture multiple targets. In close combat or law enforcement operations in military operations, it enables shooters to better perceive the surrounding situation and respond promptly.

  • Fast target capture: The wide field of vision combined with the red dot aiming feature enables shooters to detect and lock on targets more quickly, making it particularly suitable for tactical scenarios that require rapid response, such as CQB (Close Indoor Combat).


Limitations

  • Weak protective ability: The open structure makes its protective ability against harsh environments relatively poor. In environments with sand, dust, rain, etc., the internal optical components are more likely to be affected, and situations such as sand and water entering may occur, affecting the normal use of the sight.

  • Poor durability: Compared with the tubular red dot sight, the internal components of the open red dot sight are relatively exposed. When subjected to external force impact, the risk of internal component displacement or damage is relatively high, and there is a certain disadvantage in terms of durability.


 

How to choose


 

Tactical scenario determination

If tactical tasks are mainly carried out in harsh environments (such as deserts, rainforests, etc.), the protection and durability of the tubular red dot sight can better meet the requirements. If the focus is on close-range rapid response combat, with high requirements for field of vision and target capture speed, an open red dot scope is more suitable.

Personal preferences and habits

Some shooters may be accustomed to the aiming method in a narrower field of view and find the tubular red dot sight more convenient. Some Sagittarians, on the other hand, place more emphasis on the environmental perception advantage brought by a wide field of vision and tend to prefer open red-dot scopes.

 

Both tubular and open red dot sights have their own advantages and disadvantages. When making a choice, it is necessary to comprehensively consider factors such as tactical scene requirements and personal preferences in order to select the most suitable red dot sights for oneself and achieve the best performance in tactical operations.

Report this page